Values like integrity, transparency, fairness, respect, inclusion, employee well-being and ethical leadership are now features of organisational identity that are increasingly stressed by organisations. They're being articulated in corporate/corporal vision statements, mission declarations, the code of conduct, human resource policies and leadership messages. But such formal declarations of commitment are not necessarily evident to workers in their daily work lives. It can be very easy for a large difference to occur between what organisations say they value and what employees experience as managers make decisions, maintain relationships, develop organisational systems and display leadership. This paper focuses on this area by considering the culture of pretence—the environment in an organisation in which formally stated values continue to be symbolically relevant, but are only occasionally manifested in practice. Based on the Organisational Culture Theory, Behavioural Integrity, Social Exchange Theory, Psychological Contract Theory and Organisational Justice Theory, the paper provides a conceptual backdrop to understand the relationship between value – behaviour incongruence and employee perceptions and turnover relations. It suggests that consistent communications between the organisation's promise and lived experience can lead to cynicism, distrust, a violation of the psychological contract, low organisational identification and low emotional connection. Based upon the aforementioned literature and practice, the paper suggests that there are five interrelated dimensions of the Organisational Value–Behaviour Congruence Framework: espoused organisational values, enacted organisational practices, perceived value–behaviour gaps, employee psychological responses and organisational outcomes. It also explores the importance of holding leaders accountable, allowing for employees to influence and make their voice heard and helping to narrow the divide between organisational rhetoric and reality. A comparative approach is used to draw out the meaning that can be derived from institutional structures, organisational hierarchy and workplace expectations concerning organisational inconsistencies when employees experience them. The paper adds to the current human resource management and organisational behaviour literature in two ways: it put value–behaviour alignment at the heart of organisational credibility, relational trust and sustainable workplace culture. It argues that organising values are not simply expressed in declarations but through their consistent representation in the everyday organising.